Click on the image to the left to go to MSF's Darfur Emergency Timeline. Conflict has long been a part of the Sudanese political landscape, predominantly between
the ruling Arab government and black African ethnic groups. In 2004, this conflict became even more violent and deadly in the western region of Darfur. Here,
black Africans complained that the region was ignored by the government in Khartoum, the capitol. Militia groups, known as the janjaweed, backed by the government, began targeting armed opposition groups such as the Sudanese Liberation Movement/Army (SLM/A) and the Justice and Equality Movement (JEM), but the attacks also included
widespread violence against unarmed civilians.
By November 2004, the
UN reported 1.65 million persons were internally displaced in Darfur, and more than 200,000 refugees from Darfur had fled to nearby Chad. That year, the then Secretary General of the United Nations,
Kofi Annan, established an International Commission of Inquiry on Darfur. Members of the Commission conducted an investigation within Darfur from November 2004 through January 2005, and issued a
report to the Secretary General on January 27, 2005. The Report detailed the criminal actions and human rights violations in Darfur:
"Based on a thorough analysis of the information gathered in the course of its investigations, the Commission established that the Government of the Sudan and the Janjaweed are responsible for serious violations of international human rights and humanitarian law amounting to crimes under international law. In particular, the Commission found that Government forces and militias conducted indiscriminate attacks, including killing of civilians, torture, enforced disappearances, destruction of villages, rape and other forms of sexual violence, pillaging and forced displacement, throughout Darfur. These acts were conducted on a widespread and systematic basis, and therefore may amount to crimes against humanity. ... The vast majority of the victims of all of these violations have been from the Fur, Zaghawa, Massalit, Jebel, Aranga and other so-called ‘African’ tribes. ... [I]t is clear from the Commission’s findings that most attacks were deliberately and indiscriminately directed against civilians."
As for genocide, the Report remarks:
"The Commission concluded that the Government of the Sudan has not pursued a policy of genocide. ... the crucial element of genocidal intent appears to be missing, at least as far as the central Government authorities are concerned. Generally speaking the policy of attacking, killing and forcibly displacing members of some tribes does not evince a specific intent to annihilate, in whole or in part, a group distinguished on racial, ethnic, national or religious grounds. Rather, it would seem that those who planned and organized attacks on villages pursued the intent to drive the victims from their homes, primarily for purposes of counter-insurgency warfare."
The Report chose to withhold the names of perpetrators, although it did list unnamed officials of the Government of Sudan. The Report concluded by urging the
United Nations Security Council to refer the situation to the
International Criminal Court, which was done on March 31, 2005. The Chief Prosecuter of the ICC opened a
formal investigation in 2005. During the time of the investigation, the Sudanese government continued the violence in Darfur.
Doctors Without Borders/Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) has been
working within Sudan since 2003 to provide aid to the victims of the humanitarian crisis. The first exploratory MSF team responded to Chad in September 2003 to assess the status of the displaced persons there, and immediately opened therapeutic feeding centers to treat widespread malnutrition. By May of 2004, MSF had 47 international staff and hundreds of Sudanese staff in Darfur to treat victims of the conflict. In that month, MSF made a
statement to the Security Council detailing the deteriorating health status of affected Sudanese and the inadequacy of the available humanitarian aid. MSF attributed much of this inadequacy to obstacles posed by the Sudanese government:
"First and foremost, the government of Sudan is currently implementing a policy intended to drastically limit the ability of humanitarian organizations to freely and independently assess the needs of the displaced population and implement assistance programs in Darfur. In particular the exceedingly long and cumbersome visa, travel, and customs procedures have dramatically hindered and delayed assistance. ... In addition to the slow and complex procedures for obtaining visas to enter Sudan and travel permits to access the Darfur region, there are also restrictions on the flow of assets and goods. ... And in Darfur itself, various authorities are also tightly controlling our access to those in need and hampering the delivery of aid by imposing additional procedures. ... MSF has only limited access to areas of Darfur under the control of the government of Sudan and no access whatsoever to the populations in the areas controlled by the two rebel movements."
From 2004 to the present, MSF has continued to treat patients as best it can; providing care for malnutrition, hepatitis, cholera, victims of flooding and violence, as well as delivering thousands of vaccinations against measles and meninigitis. Following the release of a 2005 report detailing the terrible sexual violence committed against female Sudanese,
"The Crushing Burden of Rape," the MSF Head of Mission in Sudan and another senior MSF staffer were
arrested on charges against the state and providing false information; the charges were dropped a month later.
In 2006, the UN Security Council adopted a
resolution to deploy a peacekeeping force to Sudan, but Sudan rejected the measure. Sudan accepted a joint African Union/United Nations Hybrid (
UNAMID) peacekeeping operation, and formal operations
began on December 31, 2007. However, the violence continues, and MSF and other aid workers have come under attack. MSF was forced to evacuate areas in North Darfur in August of 2008 due to attacks.
On July 14, 2008, the Chief Prosecutor of the ICC applied to the ICC for a warrant for the arrest of Omar Hassan Ahmad Al Bashir, the President of Sudan, on charges of genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes in Darfur from 2003 to 2008. Following the application, the ICC heard testimony in support of the request from the prosecutor and from Sudanese groups. On March 3, 2009, the ICC issued a
decision and a
warrant for President Bashir. The warrant included 7 counts, with 5 counts of crimes against humanity, including murder, extermination, forcible transfer, torture, and rape, and 2 counts of war crimes. The warrant, like the International Commission of Inquiry on Darfur Report to the Secretary General, did not charge President Bashir with genocide.
Since the warrant was issued, President Bashir has defiantly opposed it;
the New York Times reported on March 5 that "Mr. Bashir called the International Criminal Court in The Hague a hangover from the worst days of colonialism and [the] indictment ... a naked grab for Sudanese resources like oil." However, Desmond Tutu, the former Anglican Archbishop of CapeTown and a recipient of the Nobel Peace Prize, rejected this thesis in
an opinion piece in the New York Times days before the warrant was issued. Archbishop Tutu reminded readers that more than 20 African countries were founders of the ICC and went on to say:
"I regret that the charges against President Bashir are being used to stir up the sentiment that the justice system — and in particular, the international court — is biased against Africa. Justice is in the interest of victims, and the victims of these crimes are African. To imply that the prosecution is a plot by the West is demeaning to Africans and understates the commitment to justice we have seen across the continent."
Days after the warrant was issued,
the Sudanese government suspended operations of 13 aid groups in Sudan including sections of MSF; the ouster was based on charges that the aid groups provided false testimony to the ICC.
MSF reported that they received notice from the Sudanese goverment to remove all international staff from Darfur on March 2 without explanation. This order was followed by the
expulsions of the Dutch section of MSF, providing aid to three sites in South Darfur, on March 4, and
the French section of MSF on March 5.
MSF reiterated its position of neutrality in a formal statement in July 2008 after the prosecutor's application for an arrest warrant and again in a
statement from Dr. Christophe Fournier, President of MSF International Council, on March 5. In these statements, MSF reports that "[all] sections have adopted a binding internal policy refraining from any cooperation with the ICC. This policy is based on the recognition that humanitarian activities must remain independent from risk of political and judicial pressure in order to be able to give medical and relief assistance to populations in situations of trouble and violence. ... We did not cooperate or send any information to the ICC and we do not as a rule comment on judicial decisions."
After the French section expulsion,
MSF reported "The vast needs of the population left unaddressed by the expulsion of so many aid organizations leaves a huge void in assistance, impossible for any remaining agency to adequately fulfill. The basic needs of hundreds of thousands of people will now go unmet, be they medical, food, and water and sanitation. Outbreaks of meningitis in Kalma Camp and Niertiti—where an estimated 130,000 people are in urgent need of vaccination—risk going completely unanswered."
Despite the expulsion of the aid groups, and the rising concern for the humanitarian situation, the
New York Times reported on March 6 that the UN Security Council could not come to agreement about possible action in response. In an opinion piece published on the same day,
the Times made recommendations that the US and allies a) block the African Union and other countries appeal to delay the indictment for a year, b) bolster troops and equipment for UNAMID, c) encourage China to stop supplying Sudan with arms, and d) name a special envoy to oversee another attempt at a peace solution.
President Bashir continues to defy the arrest warrant, with reports that
he will try to attend a meeting in Qatar at the end of March, openly challenging the ICC to find parties willing to arrest him, and
Reuters reported today that President Bashir has threatened to expel more aid groups. Since the warrant was issued, and the aid groups were expelled, the US has not yet made a response, but Nicholas Kristof, former editor of the NYT and current journalist and op-ed columnist for the paper,
wrote yesterday that Susan Rice, the US ambassador to the UN, said to him that “If this decision stands [to expel aid groups], it may well amount to genocide by other means.”
Mr. Kristof reiterated a proposal made recently by Gen. Merrill McPeak, the former Air Force chief of staff and a co-chairman of the Obama presidential campaign, in a
Washington Post opinion piece, to establish a no-fly zone over Sudan. A no-fly zone would remove the ability of the Sudanese military to terrorize the population using air strikes, a significant part of the strategy in Darfur. Gen. McPeak writes that Secretary of State Hillary Clinton had acknowledged that this proposal was under consideration during her Senate confirmation hearings.
The future of those Sudanese affected by these events is uncertain, but MSF is doing everything possible to deliver care despite the enforced restrictions.
MSF reports that MSF teams continue to provide care in West Darfur in Golo and Killin, and in North Darfur in Kebkabiya, Kaguro, Serif Umra, Shangil Tobaya and Tawila.
Please consider donating to MSF at my Ironman fundraising site to help MSF continue to deliver care in Sudan, one of MSF's Top 10 Humanitarian Crises of 2008, and many other areas of the world.